Kohler Santa Rosa vs Cimarron: In-depth Product Comparison for a Practical Choice

Last updated on April 15, 2024

In today’s discourse, we’re uncovering the distinct features of Kohler Santa Rosa and Cimarron, diving straight into their core differences, to help you discern the superior choice.

Key takeaways:

  • Santa Rosa: Sleek one-piece design, ideal for smaller bathrooms.
  • Cimarron: Traditional two-piece configuration, classic look.
  • Santa Rosa: Highly efficient 1.28 gallons per flush rate.
  • Cimarron: Some models offer dual-flush mechanism.
  • Consider personal preferences and bathroom requirements.
1of 10

Kohler Santa Rosa Vs Cimarron: A Quick Comparison

When choosing between the Santa Rosa and the Cimarron, it’s essential to consider the following: the Santa Rosa offers a one-piece design that is sleek and easier to clean, due to fewer crevices where dirt can hide. On the other hand, Cimarron presents a two-piece configuration, which can be appealing for those who prioritize traditional aesthetics and may find it slightly easier to handle during installation due to its segmented nature.

The Santa Rosa has a compact elongated bowl that provides comfort while saving space, making it ideal for smaller bathrooms. Its Comfort Height feature simulates the ease of sitting and standing from a standard chair. Contrastingly, the Cimarron comes with an option of elongated or round bowl, facilitating a choice based on personal preference and space considerations.

Both use Kohler’s AquaPiston flush technology but they differ marginally in water usage: Santa Rosa has a 1.28 gallons per flush rate which is highly efficient, while some Cimarron models offer a dual-flush mechanism, granting the user control over water consumption and the environmental impact.

With these points in mind, both toilets exhibit high-quality craftsmanship and durability one expects from Kohler, setting the stage for a more detailed analysis based on specific preferences and bathroom requirements.

2of 10

Introducing Kohler Santa Rosa

The Kohler Santa Rosa commands attention with its sleek, one-piece design, easily fitting into the modern bathroom aesthetic. It’s compact with an elongated bowl, offering comfort without compromising on space – a real advantage for smaller bathrooms.

Efficiency is at its core, sporting a 1.28 gallons per flush rating that meets EPA WaterSense criteria, ensuring water conservation without sacrificing performance. The chair-height seating makes it accessible for most users, enhancing comfort and ease of use.

Furthermore, the integrated tank and bowl remove the crevices and seams that can harbor bacteria, simplifying cleaning significantly. With various color options available, it seamlessly blends function with style, satisfying a range of personal preferences in bathroom decor.

3of 10

Introducing Kohler Cimarron

The Kohler Cimarron, with its versatile design, caters to a wide range of bathroom styles. It stands out with a traditional, classic look that suits both modern and vintage aesthetics.

Equipped with a comfortable height feature, it meets ADA compliance, making it accessible for a broader user base, including the elderly and those with disabilities.

This model boasts an efficient AquaPiston flush technology, which promotes a strong and effective flush using only 1.28 gallons per flush, emphasizing water conservation without sacrificing performance.

Additionally, the Cimarron offers an elongated bowl for added comfort and is available in several colors, ensuring that it can align with various bathroom decors.

4of 10

Are There Differences Between These Two Toilets? Which One Is Much Better?

When examining the Kohler Santa Rosa and Cimarron, several differences become apparent, and these distinctions could sway your purchasing decision based on personal preferences and needs.

The Santa Rosa model boasts a compact, one-piece design with an integrated tank and bowl, which not only offers a sleeker look but also facilitates easier cleaning. It’s an ideal choice for smaller bathrooms, given its space-saving profile.

On the other hand, the Cimarron, although available as a one-piece, is more commonly found as a two-piece. This traditional set-up provides a slightly larger water surface area and may be preferable for those looking for a classic bathroom aesthetic.

Water efficiency is a critical factor, and here both toilets perform admirably; however, the Santa Rosa edges ahead slightly with its 1.28 gallons per flush rate compared to the Cimarron’s 1.6 gallons. The Santa Rosa’s efficiency could lead to significant water savings over time.

Comfort is another crucial element, and each model offers a comfortable seat height, but Cimarron’s elongated bowl might be deemed more comfortable by some users, particularly taller individuals or those with mobility issues.

Ultimately, which one proves to be the better fit will hinge on your specific requirements concerning space, design preference, water savings, and comfort. Select wisely to ensure that your chosen model meets your bathroom’s form and function needs in the long run.

5of 10


When narrowing down your choice between the Santa Rosa and the Cimarron, consider how each fits within your bathroom’s aesthetic and space constraints. Santa Rosa’s one-piece design imparts a sleek, uninterrupted look that effortlessly complements minimalist or modern decors. Compact in size, it’s a wise pick for smaller bathrooms, gracefully saving on precious space without sacrificing style.

On the other hand, Cimarron’s two-piece configuration offers a more traditional appearance, giving a nod to classic bathroom styles. Its elongated bowl provides added comfort, making it a preferable option for many. Plus, the extra height can be a boon for taller individuals or those with mobility concerns; a subtle yet pivotal consideration. Keep in mind, each model comes in a variety of colors, with Kohler’s reputation for durable finishes allowing you to tailor your bathroom to your personal taste palette.

6of 10

Leakage and Replacement

When it comes to long-term maintenance, both the Santa Rosa and the Cimarron models have reputations for durability. However, unpredictable issues like leakage may still arise. The one-piece design of the Santa Rosa can be less prone to leaks since there are fewer seams between the tank and bowl compared to the two-piece Cimarron. Fewer parts typically mean fewer opportunities for leaks to develop.

In the event replacement parts are needed, the Cimarron’s two-piece design can be handy. Individual components can be more easily swapped out without having to replace the entire fixture. This might mean a more straightforward and potentially less expensive repair process.

Consider the environment as well. A home with children or high bathroom traffic might fare better with the Santa Rosa’s fewer crevices, whereas a DIY enthusiast might appreciate the repair-friendly nature of the Cimarron’s design. Keep in mind, though, even with a good track record for reliability, vigilance in maintenance checks helps avoid the inconvenience and cost of unexpected leaks or repairs down the line.

7of 10


When considering the prevention and ease of clearing clogs, both models present commendable features but with some distinctions. The Santa Rosa owns an advantage with its AquaPiston technology, which ensures a powerful and effective flush. Its design allows water to flow into the bowl from all sides, increasing the force and reducing the likelihood of waste sticking to the sides, thus minimizing clog incidents.

On the flip side, the Cimarron also boasts a robust flushing system but relies more on traditional gravity flush technology. Its Precision Glide trapway is glazed, facilitating waste to slide down more smoothly. While the Cimarron’s performance is reliable, the differences in flush mechanism may sway one to favor the Santa Rosa if the primary concern is clog prevention.

It’s worth noting, clogs can also be influenced by lifestyle habits. Excessive toilet paper and non-flushable items are often culprits regardless of toilet model. Regular maintenance and judicious use are key to keeping either toilet clog-free.

8of 10

Flush System and Water Consumption

When it comes to the nitty-gritty of flush performance, both contenders boast Kohler’s AquaPiston technology, a canister flush that packs a punch, pushing water in from all sides to cleanse the bowl efficiently in one go. It’s more like a 360-degree power wash for your toilet, resulting in a cleaner bowl with less water.

On the water consumption battlefield, both models are certified WaterSense toilets, championing eco-friendliness by using a thrifty 1.28 gallons per flush (GPF). This is a significant drop from the old-school 3.5 GPF toilets, ensuring these models are as kind to the planet as they are to your water bills.

In the Santa Rosa corner, the compact design integrates the tank and bowl into a seamless unit, reducing the footprint and potentially minimizing the escape route for leaks in the future.

Cimarron, however, steps into the ring with a traditional two-piece design, which means a little more effort in cleaning but offers easier component replacement. If ease of repair is your heavyweight champion, Cimarron might swing the vote in its favor.

When performance and conservation lock horns, remember, a good flush and low water use can coexist, and these two Kohler models are proof of that harmonious balance.

9of 10

Our Verdict

When choosing between the Kohler Santa Rosa and the Cimarron, the decision boils down to personal preference and specific needs. Both toilets offer impressive features, but the Santa Rosa leads slightly with its compact, one-piece design, which is ideal for smaller bathrooms. Its AquaPiston flush is also efficient and effective.

On the other hand, the Cimarron stands out with its traditional two-piece configuration, which can be more practical for certain installations and repairs. If water consumption is a priority for you, both toilets meet the strict EPA guidelines, but Santa Rosa’s 1.28 gallons per flush might just give it an edge in terms of eco-friendliness.

Ultimately, it’s about what fits your space and meets your functional requirements—whether that’s ease of cleaning, simplicity of design, or water efficiency.

10of 10


Which Kohler toilet is best for not clogging?

In my opinion, the Kohler Wellworth is the best Kohler toilet to prevent clogging due to its Class Five flushing system and large trapway.

Is Kohler Cimarron a Class 5 toilet?

Yes, the Kohler Cimarron is a Class 5 toilet.

Are Kohler toilets worth the money?

Indeed, considering their long-standing reputation for excellent durability, efficient flushing systems, and aesthetically pleasing designs, Kohler toilets can be recognized as a worthwhile investment.

Who makes Santa Rosa toilet?

The Santa Rosa toilet is manufactured by KOHLER®.

What distinct features separate Kohler Santa Rosa from Cimarron?

The Kohler Santa Rosa distinguishes itself from the Cimarron through its one-piece design, compact elongated bowl, and slightly higher seat, offering a sleeker aesthetic and potentially more comfortable user experience.

How does the efficiency and water usage compare between Kohler Santa Rosa and Cimarron?

The Kohler Santa Rosa is more efficient and uses less water than the Cimarron.

Are there notable differences in the installation process of Kohler Santa Rosa and Cimarron?

Yes, notable differences exist, with Kohler Santa Rosa’s process being comparatively straightforward due to one-piece construction, in contrast with the Cimarron’s two-piece configuration necessitating extra steps.

Continue reading:

Read more

Read more

Read more

Read more